Why do U.S. Manufacturing Jobs Always Rise Under Democrats and Fall Under Republicans?
1) Democrats will stand up against abusive trade practices without alienating our allies. When a foreign trading partner engages in abusive trade practices like “dumping” manufactured good at below their production costs, Democratic presidents have proven far more willing to stand up and fight for American jobs. In contrast, Republicans often treat this as an opportunity to bust trade unions, lower wages, or increase the profitability of their multinational campaign contributors. A recent example of this was the refusal of the Bush administration and the Republican majorities in Congress to respond to the massive currency manipulation by China in the early 2000’s. President Trump’s tariffs have so far accomplished little besides alienating our allies, damaging the reputation of the United States as a reliable trading partner, and further devastating our rural economy.
2) Democrats will take tough votes in tough times to ensure the survival of U.S. manufacturing.The vote for the Automobile bailout — a vote taken in the depths of the financial crisis, when the public was scared and angry and polling was running 70-30 against the auto bailout, and shortly after the CEO’s of the Big Three Automakers had flown to Washington in their private jets to beg for money even as they had steered their companies to the edge of bankruptcy. There is a long list of brave Democrats — myself included — who lost their seats in Congress after taking these and other brave votes to save our economy. And yet, without those votes, three million American manufacturing jobs would not exist today.
3) Democrats understand the importance of a fair and rules-based business environment, and stable and respectful international relations, to export manufacturing and economic growth. The Trump Administration’s ill-considered tariffs, spurious public intimidation of U.S. manufacturers, and erratic and inconsistent claims and promises, are no substitute for stable well-structured incentives that promote U.S. manufacturing.
4) Democrats understand the connection between manufacturing and national security. Under the Republican philosophy that the only duty of a CEO is to maximize shareholder profits, if a company can make more money by substituting a cheaper foreign component, they should go ahead — even if this comes at the cost of destroying U.S. industries like electronics or shipbuilding that are crucial to our national defense. Democrats hold a wider view of corporate responsibility — to their workforce, to our national defense, our national economy, consumer privacy, and to our environment.
5) Democrats will Fight for Tax Code that incentivizes U.S. manufacturing and keeping profits onshore. Republican tax and trade policies have consistently favored transnational companies that offshore jobs. It is not an accident that the trade deficit has skyrocketed since the passage of the Republican Tax Bill.
How Bill Foster believes we should fix U.S. Manufacturing
1) Eliminate Tax Incentives to Move Jobs Offshore.
Although overall U.S. income tax rates are the lowest in 60 years, the tax code is still littered with misguided and indefensible incentives that encourage companies to ship American-jobs offshore. Many of these were enacted due to lobbying by large corporations whose business plans were to move manufacturing operations offshore, and paid high-powered lobbyists to obtain beneficial tax breaks for doing so.
These tax incentives to move jobs offshore have to be dismantled – carefully and quickly – and Bill has been proud to vote for legislation to begin this process.
2) Stop poorly conceived and badly executed trade agreements.
In all trade negotiations, four things are always on the table: Manufacturing, Agriculture, Financial Services interests, and diplomatic considerations. Bill believes that for decades, the United States was ill-served by trade agreements influenced by special interests and their lobbyists who pushed forward the priorities of Wall Street and short-term diplomatic interests at the expense of U.S. manufacturers, workers, and farmers. Trump’s proposed trade deals to upgrade NAFTA will do little to enforce fair labor standards in Mexico and will actually increase prescription drug prices in the U.S.
3) Restore the Emphasis on Manufacturing in American Education and Culture.
Educational excellence in Science, Technology, Engineering, and Math (STEM) is crucial to success in a dynamic modern manufacturing economy. See Bill Foster’s positions on Education.
The problem is also cultural. Henry Ford and Thomas Edison were once heroes to ordinary Americans because of the products they invented and manufactured. A large and growing fraction of the students from top Universities now head to careers in Wall Street Finance instead of the real economy. It’s been decades since a leader in the manufacturing world has been recognized as a hero in our popular culture.
The key to U.S. Manufacturing is to get the next generation of students interested in building things.
One of the things Bill is most proud of in Congress is his sponsorship of Fab Labs. These are a set of state-of-the-art rapid prototyping equipment, located in storefronts and schools throughout the country, where kids and adults can drop in, design their own parts on a computer, and then have completed parts built and in their hands within minutes. Kids use the computers and equipment to design and make everything imaginable – jewelry, furniture, motors, models, or robots – using this true “workplace of the future”.